Boots in Review – Over The Knee

Oh, how I’ve missed boots! Last fall, still carrying around postpartum weight and pushing a stroller, boots were just not in the forecast. The year before that, my legs were so swollen with pregnancy, that the only boots I was comfortable in were Timberlands. But this year, this year I finally went on a bit of a shopping spree!

I’ve ordered over a dozen pairs in the effort to find the perfect one. My house turned into a warehouse filled with huge boxes scattered around the living room. (because when you order an over the knee boot, they ship it to you in the largest box they got!) Occasionally my husband would trip over these boxes, cursing me under his breath, and a toddler or a cat would tumble out of them. 

I take my job seriously, so I tried on and tested out all the boots I ordered. I have 15″ calves and wide knees so finding boots to fit can be a challange. I wrote my reviews with that in mind, but there are also boot suggestions for narrow calves at the end of the post. Take a look below and let me know which ones are your favorites!

P.S. Check back next week for an ankle bootie review 😉

Kendall and Kylie Fedra Boot

Kendall and Kylie Fedra Boot

Dark-grey suede boot with a pointy toe and lace up above the knee.

Has a comfortable 3 inch stacked heel.

Easy to put on and fits a wide calf. Tight at the thigh. Partial zippered opening.

Sam Edelman Kent Boots

Sam Edelman Kent Boots

Stretchy microsuede upper that molds to your legs!

Come in black and dark grey (shown)

Super comfortable 3 inch heel

Fit my calf even with skinny jeans on, easy to put on and take off.

Tie up in the back and side zip closure.

Carlos Santana Fringe Boot

Carlos Santana Fringe Boot

Knee high suede boots with fringe details on the side. 

Come in three colors, I’m wearing the one called Doe

Pull on style with ankle zipper (easy on but harder to take off)

Fit wide calf but a bit tight at the knee. 

Hold their shape well. Sturdy 4 inch heel.

am Edelman Bernadette Boots

Sam Edelman Bernadette Boots

These were the most gorgeous ones of the bunch. 

They came in the biggest box and, of course, they didn’t fit.

I would say they would be perfect for someone with a 14″ calf and under

4 inch high spikey heel

Genuine suede upper. Cut out at the thigh in the back.

They aren’t stretchy but rather hold their shape.

Ivanka Trump Kellyn

Ivanka Trump Kellyn

Light-grey stretchy microsuede boots, perfect for everyday

2 inch block heel, very comfortable and easy to put on.

Fits wide calves without a problem, even with jeans!

Marc Fisher Alinda Boot

Marc Fisher Alinda Boot

Suede-look textile upper that comes in four different shades (this one is the darker grey)

Stacked 3.5 inch heel, very comfortable!

Easily fits a wide calf and adjusts at the thigh. Tight at the ankle and partial side zipper.

1. Most Popular: Stuart Weitzman ‘Highland‘ – $798 – (12″ to 15″ calf)

2. Jeffrey Campbell ‘Perouze’ – $225 – (12″ to 15″ calf)

3. MIA ‘Emelia’ – $99 – (13″ to 16.5″ calf)

4. Jeffrey Campbell ‘Cienega’ Thigh High Boot – $235 (adjusts up to 16″ calf!)

5. Steve Madden ‘Rocking’ – $99 (13″ to 16 3/4″ calf!)

6. Giuseppe Zanotti ‘Alabama’ – $1750 (12″ to 15.5″ calf)

Thigh High:

1. Oscar Tiye – $1,748

2. Aquazzura Velvet Boots – $995

3. Free People Lace Up Boot – $228

Narrow Calf Boots:

4. Seychelles ‘Chrysalis’ Boots – $199

5. Joie ‘Jemina’ – $378

6. Dolce Vita ‘Chance’ – $199